Tuesday, 7 June 2005

Manila Metropolitan Government

     Continuing with the Metro Manila thread of thought… I think that all of Metro Manila’s Cities ought to be disbanded… and the entire MMDA be reorganized into a Metropolitan Government. It makes sense! Instead of each mayor having his/her own convoluted color schemes and infrastructure projects, we can have something coherent and that ties all of the City’s boroughs (if you want to be ala NYC), arrondisments (kung feeling Parisian), or districts.


 


     But the problem is… these mayors wont allow that to happen. Over their dead, decomposing, fetid bodies!


 


     The even sadder thing about this is that, it perpetuates the cycle of poverty and mistakes that has been committed… like a wound that continues to fester… unless the City’s fractured political boundaries are unified, solutions concerning housing, infrastructure, transportation, education and delivery of basic services will not be solved…


 


    Just to prove my point… Bayani Fernando was able to resettle all the squatters along the Marikina River, mainly because Marikina is not as congested as Manila and Makati… plus the fact that Marikina’s land values aren’t as high as Manila’s and Makati’s Zonal Valuations…


 


    But how about Manila and Makati, both highly urban gateway cities… which are unfortunately filled with depressed areas chock-full of urban poor… how can you relocate in-house if … number 1, your city’s land values are too high and too expensive to allocate low-cost mass housing… and number 2, if in the first place, you don’t have much land to convert/redevelop into mass housing?


 


    So what happens? They keep the urban poor captive inside their own cities… why? Because of the votes! If Makati’s poor populations were removed… the electorate would be composed of the educated middle class and the handful of rich families who live in Makati’s villages.


 


This explains why the squatters along PNR’s tracks never ever seem to leave…


 


    Now, if a Manila Metropolitan Government is instituted, this would allow the governor to relocate entire depressed communities into more open areas around the metropolis… with more space, lower land values… this allows the government to put in more money into infrastructure and transportation development, while at the same time, freeing the captive urban poor populations and maintaining the electorate status quo. A central city government would transcend petty geographical divisions!


 


Why can’t it be done? Well… you know why!

2 comments:

  1. Agreed. Unifying the metropolis under one body will be useful. However, note that the constitution and LGU codes don't allow this per se. And you'd have to go to congress etc. Not only will you have to kill the mayors, you'd have to kill the congressmen.

    I could imagine a scene such as this:
    Reporter: Sir, there are rumors that the city governments will be disbanded in favor of a unified metropolitan unit. Any comments?
    Congressman: (Muttering, glaring darkly) screw them! Over my dead body! What, and lose my position? Hell no! (To the reporter) Ah, yes, we are looking at that. No comment. (Whispering to a bodyguard) Hanapin mo yung gagong nag-sabi nun dito. Ligpitin mo. Bwiset naman o.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Come to think of it, Metro Manila might evolve as one big neural net... hehehehe... mala Pattern Language ba?! diba... each city being independent kuno...

    They say that the world's linked cities are a model for net theory... you dont have to look far... Metro Manila is exactly like that... except for the fact that the System Administrators for each server/node in the neural net is just really screwed up with his or her own agenda...

    Toss in Game Theory narin... each city/node behaving in his or her own best interest... when it should be in the context of the group...

    Hahaha... pati Chaos Theory narin... what happens in one node of the metropolis echoes in another corner...

    ReplyDelete